Basic Tubular Buckling - Work
NOTICE: Our Mathcad database got attacked and infected with a virus. Unfortunately, we've had to shut it down until further notice.
You can safely browse the pages, as the Mathcad server was separate to this main website, and was only accessible here. (We used something called an iFrame, which is like a window into a different website).
UPDATE 28th of January 2020: the virus happened just over a week ago. We've temporarily cut and pasted the text parts of the Mathcad pages rather than having blank pages there.
UPDATE 3rd of February 2020: We've been unable to recover the Mathcad worksheets and offer them in a format that provided total security to users. They were published a decade ago, and our IT people say that they would need a complete re-creation with the latest code and security fixes.
APPEAL: These 44 pages were created, and offered as a free resource for over a decade. We know from our website analytics that more than 1000 users visited each month. If only half of these regular visitors donated $20, we would have enough to create an even better solution. As you know, time is money, have these Mathcad pages saved you $20 in time over the years? We expect that they have, not to mention the learning opportunities provided to new engineers entering the industry.
Please, donate at least $20 as a one-off payment, to bring back the drillers Mathcad back as an always free to use resource!
YES! I've gotten value from the drillers Mathcad in the past, and a $20 is a very affordable way of saying thanks. I also want to preserve this tool for future engineers.
NO! I can't or won't donate to the restoration fund. I'm happy to spend a few minutes to offer a testimonial to help encourage the effort. These worksheets do have value. Offer Feedback.
Basic Tubular Buckling, release 5, issued 16 May 2008. Work version.
This worksheet exists in two versions. They are identical apart from the way they are formatted. The Work version hides intermediate calculations and allows the user to see the results just below the inputs. This is useful for quick “what-if” games, changing various inputs to see what works best. The JIT version displays all intermediate calculations, plus adds tutorial text to explain the methodology.
This worksheet takes a bunch of inputs for a tubular and it’s parameters. It uses the accepted engineering formulae to calculate the Axial Force Fa and the Stabilising Force Fs which arise from the axial (tensile/compressive) force and the internal and external pressures. These two forces added together make the Effective Force, Feff. Either of the two component forces can be negative and where the Effective Force becomes negative, it is possible for the casing to buckle. With thin walled tubes like casings and tubings, it is assumed that the tubular has no mechanical resistance to buckling.
If both ends of the tubular are fixed (such as in a cemented casing), a temperature or internal pressure increase will decrease Fa and if this decreases Feff to below zero, then buckling can occur. The temperature increase can be entered in this worksheet and the results calculated, allowing options to be explored to avoid buckling due to changes in temperature.
4.5″ 9.5 ppf4.5″ 10.5 ppf4.5″ 11.6 ppf4.5″ 13.5 ppf4.5″ 15.1 ppf5″ 11.5 ppf5″ 13 ppf5″ 15 ppf5″ 18 ppf5″ 21.4 ppf5″ 23.2 ppf5″ 24.1 ppf5.5″ 14 ppf5.5″ 15.5 ppf5.5″ 17 ppf5.5″ 20 ppf5.5″ 23 ppf5.5″ 26.8 ppf5.5″ 29.7 ppf5.5″ 32.6 ppf5.5″ 35.3 ppf5.5″ 38 ppf5.5″ 40.5 ppf5.5″ 43.1 ppf6.625″ 20 ppf6.625″ 24 ppf6.625″ 28 ppf6.625″ 32 ppf7″ 17 ppf7″ 20 ppf7″ 23 ppf7″ 26 ppf7″ 29 ppf7″ 32 ppf7″ 35 ppf7″ 38 ppf7″ 42.7 ppf7″ 46.4 ppf7″ 50.1 ppf7″ 53.6 ppf7″ 57.1 ppf7.625″ 24 ppf7.625″ 26.4 ppf7.625″ 29.7 ppf7.625″ 33.7 ppf7.625″ 39 ppf7.625″ 42.8 ppf7.625″ 45.3 ppf7.625″ 47.1 ppf7.625″ 51.2 ppf7.625″ 55.3 ppf7.75″ 46.1 ppf8.625″ 24 ppf8.625″ 28 ppf8.625″ 32 ppf8.625″ 36 ppf8.625″ 40 ppf8.625″ 49 ppf9.625″ 32 ppf9.625″ 36 ppf9.625″ 40 ppf9.625″ 43.5 ppf9.625″ 47 ppf9.625″ 53.5 ppf9.625″ 58.4 ppf9.625″ 59.4 ppf9.625″ 64.9 ppf9.625″ 70.3 ppf9.625″ 75.6 ppf10.75″ 32.75 ppf10.75″ 40.5 ppf10.75″ 45.5 ppf10.75″ 51 ppf10.75″ 55.5 ppf10.75″ 60.7 ppf10.75″ 65.7 ppf10.75″ 73.2 ppf10.75″ 79.2 ppf10.75″ 85.3 ppf11.75″ 42 ppf11.75″ 47 ppf11.75″ 54 ppf11.75″ 60 ppf11.75″ 65 ppf11.75″ 71 ppf13.375″ 48 ppf13.375″ 54.5 ppf13.375″ 61 ppf13.375″ 68 ppf13.375″ 72 ppf16″ 65 ppf16″ 75 ppf16″ 84 ppf16″ 109 ppf18.625″ 87.5 ppf20″ 94 ppf20″ 106.5 ppf20″ 133 ppf
Short RoundLong RoundButtress NormalButtress Special ClearanceOther
Select a casing
Select a connection type.
For the OD and connection selected,
additional weight per
If no data exists, you can enter a figure here for the additional weight per connection. If no value is entered in this field, then the worksheet will instead use the API nominal weight per foot to calculate downhole stresses.
Manually enter the additional weight per connection. Wtconn =
Enter the average joint length. L =
Enter the depth of the highest fixed point (eg top of cement or tubing anchor), TVD. TVDfixed =
lb per ftkg per m
Enter the pipe weight average with connections. wij =
This value is given in the worksheet “Casing Strengths”. If mixed string above TVDfixed, enter highest weight.
Enter the axial force at the surface (tensile is +ve). Fa =
Enter the internal pressure at the surface. pi =
Enter the external pressure (annular pressure) at the surface. po =
psi/ftSG or kg/lppglb/ft3ppbkPa/m
Enter the fluid gradient inside the tube. ρi =
psi/ftSG or kg/lppglb/ft3ppbkPa/m
Enter the fluid gradient in the annulus outside the tube. ρo =
Enter the expected average temperature increase with the well on production. TΔ =
(Enter -ve if well cools down instead of heats up).
Click here when any values are modified to update the result.
Axial force at the top of the pipe
Top of cement or tubing anchor depth
Neutral point for buckling at the initial temperature (depth above which the tubular cannot buckle)
If the neutral point for buckling occurs within the free pipe (the pipe above the upper fixed point eg top of cement) then the NPbuckling is plotted as a blue dotted line, below which buckling can occur.
The axial force at surface was entered as or . The minimum axial force required at the surface to avoid .
If the minimum axial force required < Fa, then the options include;
1) Picking up an additional surface force after the cement has set to make Fa exceed the minimum required surface force.
2) Raise the top of cement above , or
3) Support the casing laterally, such as by using rigid centralisers up to the NPbuckling depth.
The situation shown in the
Neutral point for buckling after the temperature change
This replots the graph above after the temperature change. The same advice as above applies, if the Effective Force goes below zero at a depth above the fixed point in the tubing.
After the temperature change, the
CHECK CONNECTION STRENGTHS vs PIPE STRENGTHS AND USE THE LEAST!!
Benham PP and Warnock FV. Mechanics of Solids and Structures. Pitman 1976.
Version 1 of this worksheet released on 5 February 2008.
Version 4 released after testing against API 5C2 found an error in one of the 8.625″ casing wall thicknesses.
Version 5 released to correct an error in the conversion factor for kPa/m.